Appeals court rules for American Express in fee dispute
American Express did not violate antitrust laws by barring merchants from asking customers to use one credit card over another and steering consumers to another form of payment, a federal appeals court said Monday.
The 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals in Manhattan tossed out a lower-court ruling, saying a Brooklyn judge erred in his February 2015 decision by focusing entirely on the interests of merchants rather than cardholders.
It said American Express seemed to get its market share based on its rewards programs and perceived prestige and “there is no reason to intervene and disturb the present functioning of the payment-card industry.” To do so, it said, likely would increase the market shares of Visa and MasterCard at the expense of American Express, whose card members tend to be more affluent than its rivals’ customers.
The written decision by a three-judge panel came in a lawsuit brought in 2010 by the U.S. government, Michigan and 16 other states against American Express, Visa and MasterCard. The lawsuit said that letting merchants steer customers to cards with lower fees for merchants or to other preferred cards would benefit consumers and increase incentives for networks to reduce card fees.
Central to the case were the fees merchants pay to process credit and debit card transactions. Those fees are largely hidden from the average consumer but are a major cost for merchants that accept credit cards. Consumers sometimes indirectly pay more for products and services as merchants pass the cost along.
The 2nd Circuit noted that credit card issuers sometimes may increase the fee charged to merchants so they can boost cardholder benefits and effectively decrease prices for cardholders.
The court said the rules American Express imposed on merchants to prevent them from steering customers to a particular form of payment “prevent a merchant from seeking high-end clientele by advertising acceptance of Amex cards but then, at the critical point of sale, offering that clientele a discounted price for not using the Amex card.”
The 16 states besides Michigan that joined the lawsuit are Maryland, Missouri, Vermont, Utah, Arizona, New Hampshire, Connecticut, Iowa, Michigan, Ohio, Texas, Illinois, Tennessee, Montana, Nebraska, Idaho and Rhode Island. The lawsuit had sought a finding that American Express’ actions violated anti-trust laws.
Copyright 2016 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.