Study: Add ultrasound to help detect breast cancer
Pittsburgh – — In the ever-changing, often complicated world of breast cancer detection, a large study led by a Pittsburgh researcher shows that ultrasound screening detected as many breast cancers as mammograms in women with dense breasts.
But don’t expect an ultrasound instead of a mammogram any time soon.
For now, the study recommends it as a complementary test for women with dense breast tissue — a situation facing about 40 percent of women age 40 and older. While the two methods spotted about the same number of cancers, the study found that more cancers detected on mammography were milk duct carcinomas in situ or DCIS while more cancers seen on ultrasound were invasive breast cancers.
Mammography uses low-dose X-rays and ultrasound uses sound waves to examine breast tissue.
“Where mammography is available, ultrasound should be seen as a supplemental test for women with dense breasts who do not meet high-risk criteria for screening MRI (magnetic resonance imaging) and for high-risk women with dense breasts who are unable to tolerate MRI,” states the study published online this week in the Journal of the National Cancer Institute.
Wendie A. Berg, a physician in the Department of Radiology at Magee-Womens Hospital, led the American College of Radiology Imaging Network protocol 6666 breast cancer screening study, which involved 2,662 womenin the United States, Canada and Argentina. Participants underwent three annual breast screenings through ultrasound and digital mammography then had a biopsy or 12-month follow-up examination.
A mammogram often cannot distinguish between white fibrous breast tissue and white tumor cells, unless calcifications are present. Berg says it’s been described as trying to see a polar bear in the snow. In ultrasound screenings, however, such tumors show up gray, making them easier to spot.
Berg’s website, DenseBreast-info.org, says dense breasts have more fibrous and glandular rather than fatty tissue. In women with extremely dense breasts, cancer is up to six times more likely than in those with fatty breasts.
While mammograms find cancers undetected by other screening tests, they can miss more than 50 percent of early cancers present in dense breasts, suggesting the need for additional screening through ultrasound or MRI.
The study, however, did find that ultrasound screening produced more false positives. Berg said they can be reduced by comparing results with previous mammograms and prior ultrasound examinations.