Expert argues PTSD at hearing
Detroit – — A Chicago Palestinian activist could have been affected by post-traumatic stress disorder when she failed to disclose on a U.S. citizenship application that she was convicted of bombings in Israel in 1969, a psychologist testified Tuesday.
Mary Fabri appeared in federal court in Detroit two weeks before Rasmieh Odeh faces trial on immigration charges. There is no dispute Odeh answered “no” in 2004 to a series of questions about past arrests, charges and convictions.
Fabri, who specializes in talking to war survivors and torture victims, said there’s a “strong possibility” Odeh was considering the questions in a narrow way and believed they applied only to her time in the U.S.
“I found her to be very credible,” said Fabri, who added Odeh has “chronic” PTSD.
U.S. District Judge Gershwin Drain heard arguments on several disputes over trial evidence, including whether to allow testimony about Odeh’s mental state and whether jurors can hear the word “terrorism.” He didn’t make any immediate decisions.
Odeh, 66, is associate director at the Arab American Action Network in Chicago. About two dozen supporters filled the courtroom for the three-hour hearing.
Odeh was convicted by an Israeli military court of placing two bombs at a Jerusalem market in 1969. One went off and killed two people. She also was convicted of bombing the British Consulate and served 10 years in prison.
But Odeh checked “no” on immigration forms in Detroit when asked if she had “EVER” been convicted of a crime or spent time in prison.
Fabri said Odeh is mentally scarred by torture by the Israeli military decades ago. Defense attorney Michael Deutsch claims she confessed to the bombings due to torture.
“It’s not that they don’t remember the past,” Fabri said of PTSD victims. “It’s automatically kept out unless there’s a stressor that weakens the defense.”
Separately, Deutsch continued his strategy of attacking Odeh’s decades-old convictions, arguing the Israeli military justice system in the 1960s didn’t resemble the U.S. justice system. The judge didn’t seem swayed.
“We’re not going to retry her case from 40 years ago,” Drain said.
Copyright 2014 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.