$5 for 3 months. Save 83%.
$5 for 3 months. Save 83%.

Health law's premium fluctuations mixed in Michigan

Ricardo Alonso-Zaldivar
Associated Press

Washington — Consumers across most of America will see their health insurance premiums go up next year for popular plans under President Barack Obama's health care law, although in Michigan and some other states, the picture is mixed.

But it will take time for families to figure out the best bang for their budgets — even as a bigger political battle brews over the program's future.

For many people, government subsidies will cushion the hit. And there's a new factor: Returning customers who are savvy about health insurance and prepared to shop for a better deal.

What independent experts analyzing the government's 2015 raw data are finding points to an overall trend of rising premiums, although not everywhere.

The nonpartisan Kaiser Family Foundation's analysis found wide differences from state to state, and even within states. Some of the steepest premium increases for benchmark plans are for counties in Alaska and Minnesota. Most counties in Georgia will see decreases. Premiums are trending up in Florida and Texas, prime targets of the administration's enrollment drive for 2015.

In Michigan, across all health plans the premium decreases can be as low as 3 percent and increases as high as 7 percent, state officials said.

The analysts have focused on "silver" plans, the coverage level picked by about two-thirds of the customers on and state-run health insurance markets. There are four levels — platinum, gold, silver and bronze. Silver is a notch below what most people with employer coverage have.

Scott Joens of St. George, Utah, said he and his wife are facing premium increases of about 18 percent for their gold plan for 2015. But instead of agonizing, he's looking for a plan with a higher deductible, which is the amount of medical expenses that consumers are responsible for each year before insurance kicks in. By switching, Joens, in his 50s and semi-retired, could lower his monthly premiums.

"It's not a major hardship," he said. "But I still have some years until I am on Medicare. My worry is by the time I'm 65, who knows where this will be?" Overall, he said he's been very satisfied with his plan this year.

A study from the market analysis firm Avalere Health found that premiums for the lowest-cost silver plan will go up 10 percent on average in communities across the country.

Kaiser took a different approach, focusing on premiums for the second-lowest-cost silver plan in every county. That type of plan is a benchmark that the government uses as a basis for setting consumer premium subsidies for the entire program.

It found that premiums for the second-lowest-cost silver plan are going up in 59 percent of counties nationwide, down in 34 percent, and remaining flat in 7 percent. Eighteen percent of counties will see an increase of more than 10 percent. At the other end of the spectrum, 13 percent of counties will see a decrease of more than 10 percent.

If you are currently in the second-lowest-cost silver plan in your community, there's no guarantee that will be the case for 2015. Another insurer may have bid lower and captured the designation. People who don't shop around could face significant price increases.

"How all this shakes out will depend on one big wild card," said Larry Levitt of the Kaiser Foundation. "Will current enrollees become savvy shoppers, or just sit back and stay in their current plans?"

The rise isn't too far out of line with what's happening to employer-sponsored plans, which cover about 150 million people and make up the biggest chunk of the health insurance market. Costs in those plans, which usually are more restrained than prices in the individual market, are expected to rise about 4.6 percent on average next year, according to a recent survey from benefits consultant Mercer.

Still, Levitt said many consumers will have the opportunity to find a lower-cost plan.

"In some places, premiums are actually going down, which is almost unheard of in health insurance," he said.

Robert Glenn of Charleston, South Carolina, is one who started looking around. The premium for his current gold plan actually dropped by $17 for 2015. Nonetheless, Glenn re-evaluated his options, figuring he would save more next year by picking a middle-of-the-road silver plan instead. His new monthly premium will be $104 less than what he is currently paying.

"I see the forces of capitalism and competition working this year," said Glenn, a psychiatrist in his early 30s who's an independent contractor. "I know I am just but one of millions of people affected … but 'Obamacare' is working for me."

Stephanie Baechle, a nanny from Columbia, Missouri, says she's not happy. Although she's in her 20s — a desirable demographic for insurers— market forces seem to be pushing more costs at her.

Her current plan is being canceled. The alternative she's being offered costs $15 a month more, and the copay is higher. On top of that, her doctor is not in the new plan.

"As a supporter of the Affordable Care Act, I am extremely disappointed in what is happening," said Baechle, who said she's considering not signing up for insurance and instead paying the fine levied against those who go uncovered.

Associated Press writer Tom Murphy in Indianapolis contributed.