FCC votes to further cut cost of calls for inmates
Kansas City, Mo. — A federal commission’s decision Thursday to further reduce the cost of jail and prison phone calls led some to hail it as a money saver for inmates’ families, but immediately prompted phone companies to threaten legal action.
Mignon Clyburn, a Democratic commissioner with the Federal Communications Commission who voted in favor of the additional cutting, said the cost of the calls have placed “incredible burdens” on the family members of the more than 2 million people incarcerated in the U.S.
Among them is Dorothee Warner, who said she has spent more than $2,000 over the past year so she and her family can talk to her jailed son.
“It is a very predatory system that is unfair,” the Overland Park, Kansas, woman said. “People who are incarcerated, it is very difficult on their families. It is almost like the family is being punished as well.”
Over the years, defense attorneys also have joined in the fight for lower rates. But phone companies have defended the costs, saying some of the money generated is used for things like activities for the incarcerated and that the calls require costly security features. The FCC has countered that the cost of security features was built into the rate structure.
Securus Technologies Inc. CEO Richard Smith said in a written statement that the FCC’s decision is a “colossal error” that threatens the financial stability of his company and other inmate phone providers. He said Securus, one of the largest providers of inmate phone services, would join other companies in a request for court intervention.
Two years ago, the FCC voted to restrict rates on inmate calls made from one state to another. The new changes go further, capping rates on all local, in-state long distance, interstate and international calls. The vast majority of inmate calls will cost no more than $1.65 for 15 minutes, although slightly higher rates will be allowed in some smaller institutions. And fees and other costs, which in some cases have boosted calls to $17 to $25 for 15 minutes, also would be limited.
The changes will take effect in prisons early next year and in jails by midyear.
Commissioners Ajit Pai and Michael O’Rielly, both Republicans, dissented, saying they believed they didn’t have the authority to take such action.
Jonathan Thompson, executive director of the National Sheriffs’ Association, said the group is “very disappointed.”
“We believe also that inmates should have this capability to call, but unfortunately these new rates in all likelihood will mean that inmates will go without the ability to call and talk to their family members,” he said. “How many, we don’t know.”
The changes don’t ban profit-sharing commissions that have benefited jail and prison operators and in some cases made calls costlier, although the amount of money coming in will likely be lower. Even before Thursday’s vote in Washington, however, some states had voluntarily moved to reduce or ban the commissions.
The petition asking the FCC to regulate inmate phone call rates was filed in 2003 after a judge dismissed a lawsuit that Martha Wright-Reed of Washington brought against a private prison company. She had struggled to keep up with phone bills while her grandson was incarcerated. The judge directed her to the commission.
Wright has since died, but Commissioner Jessica Rosenworcel said “there is no better way to honor her legacy than to finally fix the criminal costs too many families face just to stay in touch.”
Copyright 2015 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.