Navy leader calls fired carrier captain ‘naive’ or ‘stupid’
Washington – In an extraordinary broadside punctuated with profanity, the Navy’s top leader accused the fired commander of the COVID-stricken USS Theodore Roosevelt of being “too naive or too stupid” to be in charge of an aircraft carrier. He delivered the criticism to sailors who had cheered the departing skipper last week.
Acting Navy Secretary Thomas Modly harshly criticized Capt. Brett E. Crozier – and by implication those among the crew who had vocally supported him – in a lengthy and passionate speech aboard the ship, which is pier-side at Guam. Crew members are being taken off the ship to be tested for the coronavirus. At least 155 of the 4,865 members of the crew have tested positive, and the carrier is sidelined.
Modly relieved Crozier of command of the ship last week, saying he had lost confidence in him for having shown “extremely poor judgment” in widely distributing a letter pleading for an accelerated evacuation of the crew. The dismissal turned into a hot political issue, with Democrats saying Crozier was wrongly fired for defending his sailors, and President Donald Trump denouncing Crozier and backing Modly.
An unofficial transcript of Modly’s remarks Sunday circulated widely on the internet Monday. Several officials confirmed the authenticity of the transcript’s contents. Modly himself issued a brief statement saying he stood behind his remarks but had not heard a recording and therefore could not confirm every detail in the transcript.
“The spoken words were from the heart, and meant for them,” Modly said, referring to the crew. “I stand by every word I said, even, regrettably any profanity that may have been used for emphasis. Anyone who has served on a Navy ship would understand. I ask, but don’t expect, that people read them in their entirety.”
In his remarks aboard the Roosevelt, Modly acknowledged he was “hated” by some for firing Crozier. “I understand that you may be angry with me for the rest of your lives,” he said.
Modly said Crozier should have known his letter would leak to the media, allowing “sensitive information” about the ship’s condition to be published. If Crozier didn’t think this would be the result, he was “too naive or too stupid to be a commanding officer of a ship like this.”
Modly also accused Crozier of betraying his duty as an officer, while noting that he had come under heavy criticism for having fired him.
“It was betrayal,” Modly said, according to the transcript. “And I can tell you one other thing, because he did that he put it in the public’s forum and it’s now become a big controversy in Washington D.C. and across the country.”
The Navy’s top admiral, Mike Gilday, ordered a preliminary inquiry into events surrounding the handling of the crew in response to the outbreak of COVID-19 cases. The recommendations and findings by Adm. Robert Burke, the vice chief of naval operations, were expected to be submitted to Gilday Monday.
The Theodore Roosevelt crisis accelerated last week, with increasing numbers among the crew testing positive for COVID-19 and Modly seeking to defend his decision to fire Crozier, who was popular among his crew.
The reports of Modly making harsh accusations about Crozier during a speech to the crew on Sunday drew a rebuke by a leading Democrat on Capitol Hill. Sen. Tim Kaine, a Virginia Democrat, said Modly was out of line.
“Based on the transcript I’ve read, Secretary Modly’s comments were completely inappropriate and beneath the office of the Secretary of the Navy,” Kaine said in a written statement. “It’s deeply disappointing that he would deliver a speech on board a U.S. aircraft carrier suggesting that Captain Crozier might be ‘stupid’ and bashing the media for trying to report the truth. These dedicated sailors deserve better from their leadership.”
Rep. Elaine Luria, a Virginia Democrat and former member of the Navy, called for Modly to be fired for his remarks, saying they show he is “in no way fit” to lead the Navy.
Defense Secretary Mark Esper said during a Sunday talk show appearance that the decision to fire Crozier was made by Modly, but that Esper had supported him. Trump over the weekend strongly criticized Crozier for writing and distributing the letter without first consulting with his immediate superior.