Trump to black voters: 'What do you have to lose?'

Chad Livengood, and Jonathan Oosting

Dimondale — Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump sought to appeal Friday to African-American voters who typically side with Democrats, making a pitch for their support before a nearly all-white crowd at a sports complex.

Making remarks directed at black voters, he asked: “What do you have to lose by trying something new, like Trump?” He referred to Detroit’s high rates of poverty and violent crime and promised he would do better.

“What do you have to lose?” Trump asked repeatedly in the suburban Lansing venue. “You’re living in poverty, your schools are no good, you have no jobs, 58 percent of your youth is unemployed. What the hell do you have to lose?”

The New York businessman said black voters possibly could do “worse” than they have under President Barack Obama if they instead choose Democrat Hillary Clinton, who focused her efforts in Michigan’s March 8 primary on turning out African-American voters in Detroit and Flint but lost narrowly to U.S. Sen. Bernie Sanders of Vermont.

“One thing we know for sure is that if you keep voting for the same people, you will keep getting the same, exactly the same result,” Trump said.

Detroiters strike back at Trump’s black voter remarks

Libertarians, Democrats rally against Donald Trump

Trump: Mexico could become ‘car capital of world’

There were a handful of African-Americans and people of color in a crowd of at least 3,000 at The Summit Sports and Ice Complex in Dimondale, a bedroom community of Lansing in Eaton County. Kendrick Hodge, one of the few African-Americans who attended the rally, rejected claims by Democrats that Trump is a racist.

“What has he’s done that’s racist? What has he done that’s bigoted?” asked Hodge, a 40-year-old computer programmer from Lansing. “Just because other people say it don’t mean you repeat it. You’ve gotta have some proof.”

Hodge said Democrats offer black voters “a lot of talk, but no action.”

“They talk enough to get your vote and once they’ve got your vote they’re just back to the same old, same old,” he said.

Trump offered no specific policies for helping raise poor blacks out of poverty, other than his continued vow to walk away from international trade agreements that he argues have damaged the manufacturing base of cities like Detroit. He also criticized Clinton’s willingness to allow more refugees from Syria, a war-torn country facing a humanitarian crisis.

“Hillary Clinton would rather provide a job to a refugee from overseas than to give that job to unemployed African-American youth in cities like Detroit, who have become refugees in their own country,” Trump said.

Rev. Kenneth J. Flowers, senior pastor at Greater New Mt. Moriah Missionary Baptist Church in Detroit, said he was outraged by Trump’s remarks, particularly the businessman’s claim that blacks have “nothing to lose” by voting for him.

“We have everything to lose by voting for him,” Flowers said. “This man is a bigot. This man has talked against the Muslims, the Latinos. He has talked against women, he talked against those with disabilities. … He’s the one who is dividing this nation. How are you the unifier when you are the one who is spewing vitriol?”

The real estate developer made his second trip to Michigan in two weeks, another sign he isn’t giving up on winning a state where he feels his stances have widespread appeal.
A July 30-Aug. 1 Detroit News-WDIV poll of 600 likely November voters showed Clinton had widened her lead over Trump to 9 percentage points in Michigan.

Trump hits populist note

The 41-minute speech was filled with Trump’s populist message about reversing lost jobs and stopping corruption. But much of Trump’s remarks about Detroit were a repeat from his Aug. 8 speech before the Detroit Economic Club, where he blamed Democratic politicians and policies for leading to 40 percent of Detroiters living in poverty.

If elected president, Trump predicted he would get “95 percent of the African American vote” in a 2020 re-election campaign.

“Let’s see what happens,” said Ronna Romney McDaniel, chairwoman of the Michigan Republican Party. “We want him to win. Let’s put him to the test.”

McDaniel acknowledged the GOP hasn’t “done well in taking our message into those African American communities and fight for their votes.”

“When we talk about policies like school choice, when we talk about criminal justice reform, when we talk about national security, those are things we all have in common,” she said after the speech.

Jamie Anthor of Flint, a 28-year-old who was among a handful of African Americans in the crowd, said Trump’s message resonated with her.

“He’s totally for African Americans and getting them jobs, and I’m searching for a job myself,” she said. “It would just be nice to have someone back us up.”

Although Trump had very little to say about African Americans early in his campaign, he became popular with some white nationalists and did not immediately disavow support from former Klu Klux Klan grand wizard David Duke during the primaries.

“I don’t believe he’s a racist, and I’d like to see some evidence on that,” Anthor said. “I’d like to see one ounce of evidence of him saying the n-word or being racist towards anybody.”

Michigan Sen. Bert Johnson, D-Highland Park, called Trump’s comments about African-Americans “incredibly unfortunate” and “paternalistic.”

“He’s unashamedly presumptive, as though he believes that is the circumstance for all black voters in Michigan and presumes we have nothing else going for us, except to maybe come his way,” Johnson said.

Trump's Louisiana challenge

Near the beginning his speech, Trump reflected on his three-hour tour of flood-ravaged Louisiana Friday morning before he came to Michigan.

"Obama ought to get off the golf course and get down there," he said.

The White House has said Obama has received regular updates about the flooding and the federal response during his vacation. Late Friday afternoon before Trump's speech, the White House said Obama would visit Louisiana on Tuesday, indicating he is "eager" to see the damage and "wants to ensure that his presence does not interfere with ongoing recovery efforts."

Trump’s decision to tour the Louisiana flooding — while Obama remains on vacation on Martha’s Vineyard — marks a rare instance in which the businessman has sought to elevate an individual region’s plight.

During the height of Flint’s water crisis this winter, Trump did not come to the city when he was briefly campaigning in the state ahead of the March 8 Republican primary, which he won.

Clinton visited Flint twice this winter and made the city’s lead-contaminated water crisis ground zero for her campaign in Michigan.

Anthor said she does not trust Clinton’s commitment to help resolve the water crisis in her hometown.

“With the emails that came out, I don’t trust a liar. Never have, never will,” Anthor said. “I just hope that all the young people out there vote smart. Don’t vote for her just because she’s a woman.”

The speech came during a week when Trump retooled his campaign staff and started delivering more prepared remarks, ditching his off-the-cuff approach to rally speeches. But the populist theme remained.

“I am the change agent. I am your messenger," he told the Dimondale crowd.

Retired U.S. Army Gen. Michael Flynn introduced Trump and mentioned Trump’s comments Thursday night in Charlotte, N.C., that he regrets some inflammatory comments he’s made on the campaign trail.

“It shows character and leadership,” Flynn said.

Long lines extended outside the suburban Lansing sports complex ahead of Trump’s speech, with supporters singing the praises of the New York real estate mogul as they browsed at dozens of Trump merchandise tents that began setting up early Friday morning.

Rick Black of Livonia called Trump “the voice of the true silent majority,” although he said he does have concerns that the brash businessman speaks “a little bit too much off the cuff” on occasion.

“Everything else about him speaks to my heart. Everything else about him speaks to my soul,” he said. “He is saying what I’ve been screaming silently for years.”

Black, a retired business owner, said he supports Trump’s calls to build a wall between the United States and Mexico.

“Shut the borders, seal off the country, renegotiate our trade deals and restore America,” he said.

Brenda Filkins, a reading teacher from Charlotte, said she and her husband are supporting Trump because they do not like the direction the country is heading under Obama.

“We’d like to see a change,” Filkins said. “The last kind of change didn’t work for us.”

Critics have argued that Trump is not qualified to be president, but Filkins said she thinks his lack of political experience may be a net positive.

“We’re kind of in a mess right now with people who do have experience with politics, so I think a fresh perspective is a good thing,” she said.

Dave Zemer of Jackson attended the rally in a t-shirt that read “Hillary for prison” on the front, and “I’m not voting for Monica’s ex-boyfriend’s wife,” a reference to the Oval Office sex scandal involving former President Bill Clinton and then-intern Monica Lewinsky.

“I think she’s lying to the American people, and what she’s done with that email scandal is a disgrace,” said Zemer, a small business owner. “The fact that FBI director allowed her to just walk away from the whole situation, I totally disagree with that.”

(517) 371-3661

Twitter: @ChadLivengood