Column: Keep questioning FBI spy plane
Earlier this month, The Detroit News reported about a series of missions by an FBI spy plane over Dearborn. The plane, which is outfitted with a night vision camera and listening device equipment, flew over a portion of Dearborn and Melvindale for multiple nights. Melvindale has a growing Arab-American population. The section of Dearborn that was flown over have two mosques around the flight pattern of this particular spy plane.
The FBI claims that the flights over this area were not for surveilling the community and are routinely used to track drug dealers and violent extremists. In a statement, FBI Special Agent in Charge of Metro Detroit Paul Abbate stated, "The FBI does not employ aviation assets to conduct mass surveillance, nor to target specific communities…Further, the FBI Detroit Field Office is not aware of any specific or credible threats within the local Detroit Metropolitan Area."
Given a lack of transparency regarding what spy planes are really doing, as well as the FBI's track record locally, a number of questions remain unanswered.
Since the FBI stated there were no specific or credible threats, why were they flying over one particular area for multiple nights? Given that the FBI has used the problematic practice of sending informants into mosques, are they also able to take pictures of cars in one location, like in a mosque parking lot? When using their listening equipment on the spy plane, are they listening and capturing private cell phone conversations?
In recent years, the ACLU uncovered a 2009 FBI memorandum stating that Dearborn was on their radar "because Michigan has a large Middle Eastern and Muslim population, it is prime territory for attempted radicalization and recruitment by terrorist groups." There is no evidence to suggest that this mapping has ceased, even though there is not a single conviction involving a local Muslim going abroad to join an extremist group in the past decade from the community's approximately 300,000 people.
Our respective organizations' constituents, Metro Detroit, and indeed the country have much at stake in the pursuit to ensure individual rights and liberties are protected. We appreciate The Detroit News' reporting, which provoked questions about the spy plane as well as similar issues prior to this. Investigative reporting is what differentiates open and democratic societies from totalitarian ones. It is media which helps to keep the nation's citizenry informed in order that we can be more aware when holding our government accountable. From the Watergate scandal to NSA invasive snooping, media has continued to reinvigorate our national discourse pertaining to the importance of privacy rights and how government should be restricted in their capacity to monitor legal residents and citizens.
We encourage The Detroit News and other media outlets to continue probing into the activities of government agencies, as it is a necessary aspect in helping us make America live up to its stated guiding values and principles.
Fatina Abdrarraboh is director of American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee – Michigan.
Dawud Walid is executive director of the Michigan chapter of the Council on American-Islamic Relations.